magnify

I·CONnect

Blog of the International Journal of Constitutional Law
Home 2009 December
formats

The ECHR and ethnic discrimination in the Bosnia and Herzegovina constitution

The European Court of Human Rights had a holiday gift for Bosnia and Herzegovina’s smaller minority groups today. The story is widely reported; Deutsche Welle has coverage here. The court ruled that provisions of the country’s post-conflict constitution are discriminatory in violation of the European Convention on Human Rights. The suit in question, Sedjic and

Read More…

 
formats

The Irish SC and Gay Rights

Last week the Irish Supreme Court handed down a significant decision in relation to the rights of gays and lesbians living in Ireland. In McD v. L [2009[ IESC 81, the Supreme Court held that in a dispute over legal guardianship and access, a male biological parents (and sperm donor) was in principle entitled to

Read More…

 
formats

UKSC rules on Jewish school admission criteria

As the New York Times and other media outlets report, on Wednesday, Dec. 16 the newly established UKSC released its landmark ruling in a case involving apparently discriminatory admission criteria by a Jewish school in North London. According to the traditional Orthodox Judaism definition, a person may be recognized as Jewish only if his or

Read More…

Published on December 17, 2009
Author:          Filed under: Israel, Ran Hirschl, religion, United Kingdom
 
formats

The Church and Constitutional Fidelity

Nearly a month ago, the Wall Street Journal carried an interesting story on the role of the Catholic Church in the Honduran constitutional crisis. The Church, as it turns out, supported the coup (a highly contested word in this context, I know) for which they received a fair amount of criticism from Zelayistas. In the

Read More…

Published on December 14, 2009
Author:          Filed under: constitutional interpretation, honduras, hp, religion, Zachary Elkins
 
formats

Turkey’s Constitutional Court bans pro-Kurdish party

Under the 1982 Turkish Constitution, Turkey’s Constitutional Court – a stronghold of Kemalist-statist interests and an active defender of Turkey’s militant secularism – is vested with the power to order the closure of political parties whose agenda is found to be “in conflict with the indivisible integrity of the State with its territory and nation,

Read More…

Published on December 12, 2009
Author:          Filed under: European Convention on Human Rights, Ran Hirschl, Turkey
 
formats

Observations on Kenya’s Draft Constitution II: the “Birthers” were Right…

…about Barack Obama. Article 17(2) of the Draft provides that “A person born outside Kenya is a citizen if, at the date of the person’s birth, either the mother or the father of the person is a citizen . . . (a) who was born in Kenya.” In other words, if the draft passes, Obama

Read More…

Published on December 10, 2009
Author:          Filed under: hp; Tom Ginsburg, Kenya
 
formats

Addendum to Iraq’s Election Quandary

The Speaker of Iraq’s Parliament acknowledge today the inevitability of a “constitutional and legislative vacuum” as a result of the unavoidable gap between the end of the current Parliament’s legislative term and the time before elections can be conducted and a new Parliament and government formed — about two months by the Speaker’s estimation. The

Read More…

Published on December 8, 2009
Author:          Filed under: constitutional politics, election, hp, iraq, Jason Gluck
 
formats

Observations on Kenya’s Draft Constitution I

Kenya’s draft constitution is now in a period of public comment. The draft is long—over 300 articles—and is all in all a very impressive piece of work. It features a semi-presidential system, an extensive bill of rights, and significant devolution of power to the local level. If adopted, it will represent a significant transformation of

Read More…

Published on December 7, 2009
Author:          Filed under: hp; Tom Ginsburg, Kenya
 
formats

The Election Law Passed But Iraq Still Stands To Miss a Constitutional Dead Line

The impasse over Iraq’s election law has now caused United Nations officials to publicly admit what many have feared for weeks — Iraq is going to miss its constitutionally mandated deadline for parliamentary elections. Delays this past summer and fall were do to two key disagreements among Iraqi law-makers: (1) whether to have open or

Read More…

Published on December 7, 2009
Author:          Filed under: constitutional law, election, hp, iraq, Jason Gluck
 
formats

A constitutional conundrum in Fiji

There have been three coups in Fiji since independence. There have been two since the latest Constitution was enacted in 1997, following a respectable local constitution-making process. The Constitution was reinstated after the first of these, in a remarkably docile response to a judicial decision that it had not effectively been abrogated. The regime that

Read More…

Published on December 7, 2009
Author:          Filed under: Cheryl Saunders, hp